One Tree Hill

One Tree Hill This or That?

tinkerbell247 posted on Oct 30, 2009 at 11:28PM
it's simple I've seen it on other spots, couldn't see it here and thought I'd start it.

All you have to do is choose which one you prefer then create the next one for the next fan to answer and so on.

To start: Lucas or Nathan?

One Tree Hill 1410 replies

Click here to write a response...

Showing Replies 201-250 of 1410

over a year ago ns_23 said…
Peyton's house (cause I love her room)

I made this as a pick on the Brulian spot, but I will put it here too...

Brooke's dimples or Julian's grin ?
over a year ago tmenne23 said…
brookes dimples!

brooke and peyton buring lucas's letter in season 2 or brooke and peyton buring lucas's book in season 5?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
Burning his book (so sad, great Breyton moment tho)

season 6 premiere or finale ?
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Season 6 finale!!!

Taylor and Haley or Quinn and Haley?
over a year ago babyd21 said…
heart
Taylor and Haley

Brooke's energy (as in always hyper and fun) or Brooke caring (always being there for everyone)??
over a year ago notimetosleep said…
Brooke's energy

Pilot or season 2 premiere?
over a year ago iluvnaley4evr said…
can i join? lol
i pick season 2 premiere


naley or brulian?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
Naley ♥

#23 or #3 ?
over a year ago truffethedog said…
#23

Episode 1.17 or 3.14 (both Sparkle Classic)?
over a year ago Nibylandija said…
heart
3.14! :)

S7: Haley or Brooke?
over a year ago Jessica4695 said…
Brooke

Nathan/Taylor or Brooke/Felix?!
over a year ago Nibylandija said…
heart
Brooke/Felix by far! I liked them at some part.

Jeyton or Brulian?
over a year ago iluvnaley4evr said…
tough one...but i choose jeyton :]

karen or deb?
over a year ago notimetosleep said…
Karen definitely

Haley's mom or Haley's dad?
over a year ago iluvnaley4evr said…
Haley's mom

mia or chase?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
Mia

Andre or Chuck ?
over a year ago Nibylandija said…
heart
Chuck, lol.

Brathan or Brulian?
over a year ago notimetosleep said…
Brulian

Jake or Julian?
over a year ago Nibylandija said…
heart
Jake! No doubt. <3

Lucas or Clay?
over a year ago truffethedog said…
I'm not a big fan of neither. Rather Lucas though.

Episode 4.09 (the state championship) or 4.21 (season 4 finale)?
over a year ago iluvnaley4evr said…
both good episodes...i choose 4.21

haley's hair in season 3-4 or haley's hair in season 5?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
Her hair always looka awesome but I will go with s5

Sawyer as a girl name or a boy name ?
over a year ago tmenne23 said…
boy..

road trip to the cabin or road trip to honeygrove?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
totally agree on the fact tht Sawyer should be a boys name. lol

Anyway, roadtrip to Honeygrove ♥


Alex or Alexander?
over a year ago Naleyluv23 said…
Alexander.... i am not a very big alex fan... THIS IS FUN!!!!

Season 1 or Season 6?
over a year ago J-C said…
Season 1 by far.

Lucas beating Dan's tombstone with a shovel or Karen throwing a chair threw Dan's office window?
over a year ago oth_leyton_tla said…
Karen throwing a chair through Dan's office window, that was great :)

Haley's hair blonde in season 3 & 4 or dark in the rest of the seasons?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
Dark (but it looks great both ways)

Brooke high off special brownies or off pills (1x06)
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
High of pills

Brooke slapping Rachel or Haley slapping Rachel?
over a year ago iluvnaley4evr said…
haley slapping rachel :) that was awesome! lol

lucas and anna or felix and brooke?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
both were pointless but I will say Lucas and Anna

Mouth doing kareoke (dare night) or Nathan doing kareoke (with Chase)
over a year ago J-C said…
Ugh, Mouth doing karaoke, it wasn't as lame since he already is.

Fat Rachel pictures vs a wailing Haley on a bridge?
over a year ago truffethedog said…
Wailing Haley

Peyton slapping Chris Keller or Karen slapping Lucas?
over a year ago iluvnaley4evr said…
Peyton slapping Chris Keller

season 1 or season 3?

over a year ago notimetosleep said…
season 3


Nathan's scenes with Deb or Dan?
over a year ago Nibylandija said…
heart
Nathan's scenes with Deb, more hilarious.

Anna or Felix?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
I didnt really like either one but, Felix - hot bastard :P


Julian & Peyton or Julian & Alex ?
over a year ago iluvnaley4evr said…
julian and peyton...loved their scene in 6x23 about him loving 98 degrees!

lucas and haley or brooke and haley?



over a year ago truffethedog said…
Lucas and Haley

Whitey's scenes with Dan or with Keith?
over a year ago Nibylandija said…
heart
Whitey's scenes with Dan (especially the emotional one in s6). :'(

Naley: s6 or s7?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
Gaah ! Both <3 ... but s7 - good storylines, they've been making me cry, they love eachother so much ♥

Clay and Quinn or Clay and Sara?
over a year ago Nibylandija said…
heart
Clay and Sara. BY FAR.

Brulian: s6 or s7?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
s6 easily ! lol

Naley with or without Jamie ?
over a year ago cissy121 said…
Naley without Jamie

Lucas cheating on Brooke or Nathan cheating on Haley
over a year ago truffethedog said…
Lucas cheating on Brooke

Peyton's white dress for the real prom or the blue dress in Honey Grove prom?
over a year ago Nibylandija said…
Peyton's white dress for the real prom.

Brucas: s5 or s6?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
s5

Grubbs or Miranda?
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Miranda... I guesse

Haley's second wedding dress or Brooke's red maid of honor dress?
over a year ago iluvnaley4evr said…
Haley's second wedding dress

lucas and jamie or brooke and jamie?
over a year ago truffethedog said…
Brooke and Jamie

The Comet or Unkindness of Ravens (which would you want to read more?)
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!