One Tree Hill

One Tree Hill This or That?

tinkerbell247 posted on Oct 30, 2009 at 11:28PM
it's simple I've seen it on other spots, couldn't see it here and thought I'd start it.

All you have to do is choose which one you prefer then create the next one for the next fan to answer and so on.

To start: Lucas or Nathan?

One Tree Hill 1410 replies

Click here to write a response...

Showing Replies 601-650 of 1410

over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Lucas and Peyton ;D

Brooke and Clay or Haley and Julian?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Brooke and Clay

Andy or Cooper ?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Cooper.

Stopped at season four or Stopped at season eight?
over a year ago Drisina said…
better if they stopped at season 4 for a lot of reasons :D

3x01 or 4x01 ?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
3x01 :)

Music or Fashion?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Music all they way <3 , one of my passions :D

Felix or Chris ?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Chris just because of all the funny one liners.

Taylor or Quinn?
over a year ago ivenceto0o said…
Quinn

S1 or S7 ?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Season 1 all the way

Nathan or Julian ?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Nathan :D

Brachel or Paley?
over a year ago Drisina said…
hmm Brachel :D

Whitey or Keith ?
over a year ago Elbelle23 said…
Awww Whitey :)

Breyton or Baley
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Breyton :D

Nathan and Whitey or Lucas and Whitey?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Nathan and Whitey , at least after season 1 :D for sure :D

(high-school)Gigi or Shelly ?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
:-S gigi?

Brooke and Nathan or Peyton an Nathan (friendship)
over a year ago Drisina said…
Peyton and Nathan

Tim or Fergie ?
over a year ago Naleyluv23 said…
TIM... most definitely



Taylor James or Jimmy Edwards
over a year ago dalma said…
Jimmy Edwards...but love both!
Junk or Skills?
over a year ago Drisina said…
The brother Skills :))

Peyton in season 2 or season 3 ?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Love her in both but season 3 :)

Clothes Over Bros or Red Bedroom Records?
over a year ago Drisina said…
I like music a bit more so i guess Red Bedroom Records

more dramatic is :Keith's death or Q's death ?
over a year ago Elbelle23 said…
Keith's Death

James Lucas Scott or Sawyer Brooke Scott
over a year ago Drisina said…
James Lucas Scott

Brooke/Nathan or Taylor/Nathan ?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Defiently Brathan :)

Keith or Cooper?
over a year ago dalma said…
Keith!
Karen or Deb?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Karen

Brulian or Jeyton ?
over a year ago Naleyluv23 said…
Jeyton, but as a friendship... I hate Julian.

One Tree Hill in High School Or One Tree Hill after Highschool?
over a year ago Elbelle23 said…
One Tree Hill in High Schoool

Dan and Lucas or Dan and Nathan?
over a year ago Drisina said…
ehm... Dan and Nathan especially in season 4

Leyton in season 4 or Leyton in season 6 ?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Season 6<3

Kate Voegele or Tyler Hilton?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Tyler Hilton by far

Rachel in season 3 or Rachel in season 7 ?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Season three = drama

One tree hill without Nathan or without Brooke?
over a year ago Drisina said…
damn a hard one .. hmm i guess without Brooke i couldn't handle without Naley <3

Jimmy Eat world concert in 2x22 or Fall Out Boy concert in 3x04 ?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
Jimmy Eat world concert in 2x22

Nathan's flashback after his car accident 2x19 or Haley's flashbacks underwater 7x22
over a year ago Naleyluv23 said…
Nathans 2:19

Sophia Bush or Hilarie Burton
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Hilarie :D

Jeyton or Pulian?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Jeyton all the way one of my fave couples <3

Alex or Millie ?
over a year ago Kirkir said…
Alex

Sophia Bush or Bethany Joy ?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Bethany Joy , but I like Sophia to :]

Lincas wedding or Keith/Emily wedding ?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Mehhh Keith Emily?

Would you rather that it was Hayley and Lucas in Libary in 3.16 or Brooke and Lucas???
over a year ago Elbelle23 said…
Brooke and Lucas, we need naley in tutor center

Bevin or Theresa?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Bevin cause she is funny :))

Boy Toy auction dates in 1x18 or Fantasy Boy Draft dates in sx07 ?
over a year ago leyton23 said…
Boy Toy 1:18

Bevin and Tim or Bevin and Skills?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Bevin Skills

Peyton or Rachel ?
over a year ago Naleyluv23 said…
Peyton..... but i love Rachel

Tim Smith OR Chris Keller?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Chris Keller , love Tim to but still Chris(HellinKeller :)))

Bevin/Skills or Peyton/Jake ?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Peyton/ Jake

When everyone goes to honeygrove season 4 or when everyone goes to game in 1.06 (the one where Brooke goes High...)
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
The game in 1x06 :)

Naley's first kiss or Naley's first rain kiss?

over a year ago Elbelle23 said…
Naley's first rain kiss (l)

Lucus's letters to Brooke or Brooke's Letter's to Lucus
over a year ago Drisina said…
Brooke's letter to Lucas

Karen or Ellie ?
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!