One Tree Hill

One Tree Hill This or That?

tinkerbell247 posted on Oct 30, 2009 at 11:28PM
it's simple I've seen it on other spots, couldn't see it here and thought I'd start it.

All you have to do is choose which one you prefer then create the next one for the next fan to answer and so on.

To start: Lucas or Nathan?

One Tree Hill 1410 replies

Click here to write a response...

Showing Replies 1201-1250 of 1410

over a year ago AdaLove said…
Season 3 DVD cover


Ellie or Karen?

over a year ago saramanusson said…
Karen!

a boy or a girl (for Brulian`s child)?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
A boy :)

Flashbacks or Parallels?
over a year ago carambolas said…
Flashbacks

Season 1 finale or season 5 finale?
over a year ago ShowWhite said…
Season 1 finale

Clay and Quinn or Chase and Alex?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago bdavisrocks said…
Ooh..that's a toughie [for me :)] But I gotta go with Clay/Quinn. Alex/Chase are my new obsession though :)

Worst middle name...Bob or Eugene? :)
over a year ago XxXrachellXxX said…
Eugene :P

Clay&Sara or Brooke&Chase
over a year ago rorymariano said…
Clay&Sara

Better name: Haley Bob or Lydia Bob?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Haley Bob.

Jophia or Brulian?
over a year ago XxXrachellXxX said…
Brulian

"true love always" or "always and forever"?
over a year ago AdaLove said…
true love always


karen and andy or karen and keith?
over a year ago ShowWhite said…
Karen and Andy

Lucas&Anna or Brooke&Felix
over a year ago AdaLove said…
brooke &felix

Brooke and Julian or Sophia and Austin?
over a year ago saramanusson said…
big smile
Brooke and Julian!

Brooke Davis or Brooke Baker?
over a year ago XxXrachellXxX said…
Brooke Davis

Millicent or Rachel?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Rachel:)

Crossover Couples or AU?
over a year ago XxXrachellXxX said…
Crossover couples, I think.

Lucas&Haley vs Brooke&Peyton (surely asked before, sorry)
over a year ago carambolas said…
Brooke % Peyton

Peyton/Nathan or Brooke/Nathan?
over a year ago 123Naki456 said…
Peyton/Nathan <33

Peyton or Haley?
over a year ago rorymariano said…
Peyton {My favorite TV character}

Sawyer or Baby Lydia?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Sawyer

Lucas or Julian ?
over a year ago ShowWhite said…
Lucas

Haley's hairstyle season 1 or Haley's hairstyle season 5?
over a year ago XxXrachellXxX said…
Season 5

Taylor or Quinn?
over a year ago XNaley_JamesX said…
Taylor

Davis Baker or Jude Baker? LOL
over a year ago saramanusson said…
Davis Baker!

Brooke & Julian naming their son Davis after her name, good or dumb?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Dumb but I suppose it was gonna happen.

Brooke and the twins or Haley and Lydia?
over a year ago XxXrachellXxX said…
agree with you about Davis. What is it with the people in Tree Hill naming their kids after their last names?? - James, Sawyer & Davis

anyhow, Haley and Lydia :)

Should have there even been a season 7? Yes or no?
over a year ago rachelothfan26 said…
yes there should have been a season 7 the only reason i say this though is that the season 8 finale was incredible and also lucas and payton may come back for season 9 :)

Anyhow, joy tweeted that it was our decision what colour her hair will be for season 9 what do you think blonde or brunette?
over a year ago XxXrachellXxX said…
Blonde, absolutely!

Peyton with blond hair or that sorta ginger hair she had in the end of season 6?
over a year ago saramanusson said…
end of season 6

Best Lucas season hair?
over a year ago 123Naki456 said…
What is it with the people in Tree Hill naming their kids after their last names?? - James, Sawyer & Davis
Agree. WTF?!

Season 5 :)

James Lafferty or Chad Michael Murray?
over a year ago XxXrachellXxX said…
Chad Michael Murray

Lindsay or Anna?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Anna

Laley in season 1 or Lathan in season 2 ?
over a year ago naleyforever26 said…
Laley no doubt! :) i love them

which friend of jamies do you prefer he have scenes with
chuck or andre?
over a year ago XxXrachellXxX said…
Chuck

Naley wedding (season 3) or Leyton wedding?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago Eirinaki_b_13 said…
Naley wedding! So fairytalish!

Which was worst? Lucas having a heart condition and not being able to play basketball, or Haley giving up music for so long so she could be with Nathan and then Jamie?
over a year ago energizerbunny said…
Lucas having a heart condition and not being able to play basketball.

Cocky Teen Nathan or Mature Adult Nathan?
over a year ago Eirinaki_b_13 said…
Hmm, Cocky teen Nathan (after he met Haley), I think he was more funny and interesting!

2.05 (I will Dare) or 5.07 (In Da Club)
over a year ago Drisina said…
2.05 ♥

Deb/Skills or Dan/Rachel ?
over a year ago AdaLove said…
Dan/Rachel


Naley season 1 or naley season 8?
over a year ago sydneybreon21 said…
naley season 1



should leyton be brought back? yes or no?
over a year ago 123Naki456 said…
YES!

BJu or Jeyton?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
BJu anyday:)

Larry 1 or Larry 2?
over a year ago energizerbunny said…
Larry 2


Worse Mother: Deb or Victoria
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Victoria, because she was NEVER there.

Best Addition: Lydia or The Twins?
over a year ago AdaLove said…
The Twins . :)


Season 3 finale or Season 5 finale?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago energizerbunny said…
Season 3 finale

Sadder death: Jimmy's or Quentin's

over a year ago XxXrachellXxX said…
Jimmy's.

which airport scene: Leyton reunited in season 6 or Brucas comforting in season 5?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Leyton in Season 6 of course;)

Season 1 Brooke or Season 8 Brooke?
over a year ago XxXrachellXxX said…
Season 1 Brooke

Brooke's hair: Curly or straight?
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!