One Tree Hill

One Tree Hill This or That?

tinkerbell247 posted on Oct 30, 2009 at 11:28PM
it's simple I've seen it on other spots, couldn't see it here and thought I'd start it.

All you have to do is choose which one you prefer then create the next one for the next fan to answer and so on.

To start: Lucas or Nathan?

One Tree Hill 1410 replies

Click here to write a response...

Showing Replies 501-550 of 1410

over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Nathan :D Lucas has a dodgy history with girls that arent Peyton lol

urmm, season one or two?
over a year ago OTHjovana said…
S2 I guess...
No Brooke/Luke/Peyton love triangle... I liked Brooke/Felix, and Jeyton was OK, too. Taylor appeared and I love her :) I also loved Keith & Jules :))), and Karen & Andy were OK. Although my fave couple (Naley ;-)) was having a hard time, this was pretty good season...

Quentin or Sam ???
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago iluvnaley4evr said…
Quentin

quentin's death? or jimmy's death?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
^ which one was sadder: Quentin :'(
But it was also an amazing episode <3

Naley on the dock in 6x23 or Naley on the dock in 1x11
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Naley on the dock in 1x11 <3

Lucas saying "your art matters" to Peyton in season one or Peyton saying "your art matters" to Lucas in season five?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Lucas > Peyton in season one.

Lucas/ Peyton back with Nathan/ Haley gone
Or Lucas/ Peyton back With Brooke\ Juillian gone?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Thats so difficult to choose! I dunno, love Brulian more but the show wouldn't be right without Naley. So I'd have to choose with Brulian gone.

Keith/Jules Wedding or Lindsey/Luke Wedding?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Keith/Jules :D

Jake or Lucas ?
over a year ago OTHjovana said…
Jake

Alex/Clay kiss 7x03 or Alexander/Victoria kiss 7x18 ???
over a year ago iluvnaley4evr said…
well i like quinn and clay soo i gotta go with alexander/victoria

nathan asking haley for a divorce or haley asking nathan for a divorce?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
Haley askin Nathan for a divorce was sadder :(
(I knew Nathan didnt mean it, besides he said they had a year to see what happened)

Whats worse: Long breaks between seasons or long breaks between episodes?
over a year ago -carola-fan- said…
That was a hard one but I have to pick the breaks between the episodes

Rachel and Dan or Rachel and Nathan?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
I prefer Racgel and Dan I guess, She should be no where near Natie boy.

Anna and Lucas or Felix and Brooke?
over a year ago dalma said…
Felix and Brooke
season 2 or season 5?
over a year ago Drisina said…
season 2 by far , i didn't really like season 5 and season 2 is my fave :D

Shelley/Mouth or Milli/Mouth ?(Shelley from season 4 , the head of the clean teen club)

over a year ago dalma said…
Shelley/Mouth, I still haven't watched season 7, bu Millie annoys me so much =D

Taylor or Quinn?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Well I love Taylor for entertainment but quin is lovely.

Peytons art or Peytons Car the Coment
over a year ago Drisina said…
Peyton's art <3

Peyton loosing Ellie or Kare-Lucas loosing Keith ?(which was saddest or which you liked most :P)
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
I think when peyton found out, dropping the records. Although the after math of losing Keith was so so so sad. (I'm such a con, these last few I've been unable to choose)

Brucas or Brulian?
over a year ago dalma said…
Karen and Lucas losing Keith was way sadder for me, but I cried while seeing both :(
Skills/Bevin or Skills/Deb?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
I cried at both too

Bevin Skills :L
I loved Bevin. She always made me laugh xxx
over a year ago Drisina said…
Brucas :D loved them , i love Brulian to but Brucas wins :D

Whitey or Dan ?

over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Whitey :)

Taylor or Quinn?
over a year ago Drisina said…
hmm... well i guess Taylor cause i liked her in season 2 and Quinn i don't know i don't really like her:D

Brooke or Peyton ?
over a year ago dalma said…
Peyton! But I don't hate Brooke, as a lot of Leytoners do. :P
season 3 or season 6?
over a year ago Drisina said…
hmm i guess season 3 was better :D

Cooper or Nathan ?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Nathan!

What would have been sadder Peyton dying after being shot or Alex dying after self harming herself?
over a year ago iluvnaley4evr said…
peyton dying after being shot...

the time when haley caught leyton kissing in the library or caught them kissing at tric?
over a year ago Drisina said…
in the library , i care more about Brooke not Lindsey :D

Anna or Felix ?
over a year ago dalma said…
weeeeell, let's say, Felix, he was handsome, Anna was annoying.
Anna/Lucas or Brooke/Felix?
over a year ago Drisina said…
hmmm Anna/Lucas i guess

Brucas breakup in s1 or in s4 ?
over a year ago dalma said…
s4...
old core 5/new core?
over a year ago iluvnaley4evr said…
old core 5
i miss it so much :'(

uhmm season 5 premiere or season 6 finale?

over a year ago Leytonfan4ever said…
Season 6 :D


Brulian or Brucas?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
Brulian ♥

Julian or Clay ?
over a year ago Drisina said…
hmm I guess Julian :D , but Clay is cool to :D

Keith or Cooper ?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Cooper.

Jake or Clay?
over a year ago Margooterd said…
Jake, I don't wacth season 7

Peyton in season 5 or Peyton in season 6
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Obviously loved her in both but she was happy in season 6, so i'll go with that one :).

Alex or Anna?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Anna

Peyton's hair in season 3 or Peyton's hair in season 6 ?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Her hair in season 6 :). Both were gorgeous though.

Brooke in season 3 or Brooke in season 5?
over a year ago Margooterd said…
Brooke in season 5

Haley's hair in season 4 or Haley's hair in season 6
over a year ago Drisina said…
Haley's hair in season 4

Sam or Haley (Haley in high school) ?
over a year ago dalma said…
Haley
Lucas' hair in season 1 or 2?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Lucas' hair in season 1

Peyton/Nathan or Peyton/Chase ?
over a year ago BlairChuckFan said…
big smile
Peyton/Nathan

Naley or Brucas?
over a year ago Drisina said…
as much as I love Naley i will go for Brucas.

Rachel/Dan or Rachel/Nathan ?

over a year ago iluvnaley4evr said…
rachel/dan

haley's first wedding ring or second wedding ring?
over a year ago Drisina said…
first wedding ring <3 more traditional

Shelly or Milli ?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
ew neither! but if i had to pick Millie.

Nathan/Chris or Nathan/Skills?
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!