One Tree Hill

One Tree Hill This or That?

tinkerbell247 posted on Oct 30, 2009 at 11:28PM
it's simple I've seen it on other spots, couldn't see it here and thought I'd start it.

All you have to do is choose which one you prefer then create the next one for the next fan to answer and so on.

To start: Lucas or Nathan?

One Tree Hill 1410 replies

Click here to write a response...

Showing Replies 901-950 of 1410

over a year ago bdavisrocks said…
tinkerbell247 you didn't answer inlovewith's question so i'll answer both...
better father/son relationship...i guess nathan/dan
friendship: brooke/haley

better song for one tree hill? i don't wanna be or this is our town?
over a year ago Drisina said…
I don't wanna be(but just by Gavin)

B.Davis in season 1 or 4 ?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Ooohhhhh whoops sort for forgetting to answer it's my thread too sorry. I guess I woulda said Nathan/Dan too

And Brooke in season one.

Signing Jimmys yearbook or Quintens desk?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Jimmy's yearbook

Nathan almost drowning in season 3/4 or Haley almost drowning in 7 ?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Nathan u guess purely because f the storylines that surrounded it.

When oth is unrealistic eg peytons death angel or when oth follows a more relatable storylines?
over a year ago ladybug70981 said…
Relatable storylines.

Brucas i love you in 3x09 OR jeyton i love you from jail
over a year ago Drisina said…
Uhm both ?xD.But if i had to choose even tho kidna tied ..uhm.. Brucas :D

Robert or Shantel ?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Robert, I guess.

Baby James or CMM?
over a year ago ladybug70981 said…
Baby James...CMM + Paris Hilton = I hate him xD

Lucas/Lindsay or Brooke/Chase?
over a year ago bdavisrocks said…
Brooke/Chase

Hil and Joy or James and Joy (friendship)?
over a year ago Drisina said…
James and Joy

Jeyton first kiss or Brase first kiss ?
over a year ago Eryn6232150 said…
Brase first kiss

funny scenes: Brooke & Jamie or Leyton & Jamie
over a year ago ladybug70981 said…
Brooke & Jamie

Karen or Deb?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Karen

Dan or Keith
over a year ago bdavisrocks said…
Keith...

Alex or Mia?
over a year ago ladybug70981 said…
uh, Mia i guess

Peyton/Death or Peyton/Life
over a year ago Drisina said…
Peyton/Life

Leyton flashbacks in season 3x21 or Naley flashbacks in season 7 when Haley almost drown ?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Leyton flashbacksw in 3x21 ♥♥

Every Night Is Another Story or The Pilot?
over a year ago carambolas said…
The Pilot!

Brase or Browen?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Brase

Mia and Chase or Alex and Chase
over a year ago rorymariano said…
Browen, I guess.

3.17 "Who Will Survive, and What Will Be Left of Them" or 6.03 "Get Cape. Wear Cape. Fly."

over a year ago ladybug70981 said…
3x17. season 3 owns season 6 in every possible way. in my humble opinion that is

season 2 or season 5?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Season 2 ♥my fave season ever

2x19(Nathan's car crash)or 6x23(Peyton's uhm haemorrhage-bleeding i mean dunno if i spell it right xD)?
over a year ago ladybug70981 said…
2x19 car crash

Nathan/Peyton or Nathan/Brooke
over a year ago bdavisrocks said…
rorymariano u didn't answer tinkerbell247's question so I'll answer both.
tinkerbell247: alex/chase mia needs to back off and not be another peyton. and as for ladybug70981's question I wud have to neyton although I I prefer both couples as friends.
ok...Brooke the devil or Brooke the orange?

over a year ago rorymariano said…
Brooke the devil, it was classic Brooke. Although her as the orange was hilarious.

Haley hit by car (4.09) or Dan hit by car (5.18)
over a year ago ladybug70981 said…
dan hit by car, 5x18

Father Figure/Son relationship; Nathan/Dan or Lucas/Keith?
over a year ago Elbelle23 said…
Lucas/Keith

Gigi/Mouth or Shelbey/Mouth?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Gigi/Mouth at least in season 4 when she wasn't a slut xD

Stephen Coletti(Chase) or Robert Buckley(Clay) ?

i am so glad this thread is now way more populated ♥before it was just me and leytonfaan_18
over a year ago ladybug70981 said…
Robert Buckley

Friendships: Lucas/Haley or Nathan/Clay
over a year ago Eleana said…
Lucas/Haley

Naley or Brulian?
over a year ago bdavisrocks said…
Brulian...Naley is barely getting any scenes together anymore which annoys me. Brulian is sooo cute this season!! And I'm not saying that Naley hasn't been cute, it's just Brulian has been cuter.
Ok...so far naley scenes with Haley's pregnancy in s4 or s8?
over a year ago ladybug70981 said…
season 8. naley are literally the only thing about OTH i still like at this point.

Brucas or Brulian?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
i am so glad this thread is now way more populated ♥before it was just me and leytonfaan_18
So true! Glad there are more here now :D

And... Brulian by miles :D

Brathan or Laley?
over a year ago Eleana said…
Laley<3

Jeyton or Leyton
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Well this may come as a shock but, LP ;D

Haley in Season 1 or Season 3?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Both but Tutor girl ♥

8x06(Halloween episode)or 8x09(Thanksgiving episode) ?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
That's impossible, i'm really hating Season 8 right now. But i'll go with the Halloween one.

This spot's banner or icon?
over a year ago ladybug70981 said…
Both :) but banner if i had to pick

Brucas/Naley/Jeyton or Brulian/Naley/Leyton
over a year ago Drisina said…
Brucas&Naley&Jeyton♥

Fights:Leyton 5x16 or Brucas 3x22 ?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Leyton :')

Season 2 sleepover or season 2 dare night
over a year ago Drisina said…
Dare night

Dan season 1 or season 3 ?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
How about never? XD. Hmmmm, Season 1.

Peyton Scott or Brooke Baker?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Peyton Scott sounds way better

Season 2 sleep over or season 7 Braley sleep over ?
over a year ago bdavisrocks said…
ooh tht's a toughie but i hav to go with season 2. tht sleepover was just CLASSIC! although i thought the season 7 braley sleepover was hilarious. i loved them when they were high!

ok...baley season 3 or 7 (my two favorite seasons for them)?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Season Three?

Young Dan/Keith or Peytons Death Angel?
over a year ago ladybug70981 said…
young dan/keith

brucas season 5 flashbacks or leyton season 5 flashbacks
over a year ago Shiningsapphire said…
leyton season 5 flashbacks

High school years or atfer college years?
over a year ago ladybug70981 said…
high schoool years.

season 3 brooke or season 7 brooke
over a year ago Drisina said…
Season 3 Brooke

Carrie or Katie ?
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!