Now I realy liked Evolution, but TAS ,in my mind, was everything that an X-men cartoon should be.

i like x men evolution alot, this was a hard choice for me because i wach both of them and like them both alot.

The original X Men series was the best in my opinion. They had the most characters, it was the most faithful to the comics, not to mention my favorite characters starred in episodes (Cable if you don't know me.) I loved Evolution and it helped introduce me to new characters but it can't hold a candle to the original.

I agree that if you're going for what an X-men cartoon should be, then I'd pick Evolution as my least favorite, but I actually like Evolution a lot more. I provided me with my favorite characters in new and exciting ways, didn't overload on trying to fit too much into one episode, and I didn't have to watch the annoying Jean-Scott-Logan love triangle I dispise so much. I agree it was entertaining at first, but I really think that TAS overdid some things, and that was one of them. Also, Scott and Jean AND Logan AND the Brotherhood Boys didn't look like they had too big of sticks up their asses in Evolution. Everyone seemed to be a lot more likeable in this series to me. I just wish they would have done a few more seasons.