Supernatural

Supernatural This or That Game (Winchester Variety).

linalin posted on Mar 03, 2009 at 04:35PM
Found this game in Supernaturalfanwiki, and you must give two choices- Supernatural related- and the respondent must choose their favorite, then present two of their own.

I'll go with:

Dean's sawed-off
or
Sam's Colt

Supernatural 427 replies

Click here to write a response...

Showing Replies 151-200 of 427

over a year ago Kaidi said…
ok, not the best episode in my opinion too.
Demon hunting, the best "creatures" in that show. :)

Ok, now I'm cruel :(
Dean being electrocuted (Faith)
or
Dean in a car crash (In My Time of Dying)


over a year ago linalin said…
Damn you, Kaidi... *tear*

Dean in car crash, I thought he died when he got electrocuted, at least in the car crash I was used to Supernatural and its habits of trying to kill Dean!

Demon
or
Angel
over a year ago Dean-girlx said…
Angel.

young!John getting his neck snapped by the YED [4x03]
or
Samuel Campbell hosting the YED [4x03]
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago fanfly said…
Samuel Campbell hosting YED- that actor did an excellent job and it was so cool to "see" YED again!

YED John Winchester
or
YED Samuel Campbell
over a year ago 67impala said…
Both, lol! Ok, slight edge going to....YED John Winchester. (I agree 100% that Mitch Pileggi playing YED Samuel Campbell was fantastic!!)

Fredric Lehne as Azazel
or
Christopher Heyerdahl as Alastair
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago fanfly said…
heart
Oh you're just EVIL making me choose between those two! I love them both. Grrrr. Well ok if I have to choose....
Christopher Heyerdahl as Alastair- That voice!

Katie Cassidy as Ruby
or
Genevieve Cortese as Ruby
over a year ago toti8 said…
Of course Katie Cassidy as Ruby!I think that the Impala acts better than Genevieve!The only moment when I saw her act was when she smirked while Sam was drinking her blood.

Dean and Bela
or
Dean and Anna
over a year ago Kaidi said…
Dean and Bela. I loved that character, those fights and Bela's stealing skills were so good.

Sam and Sarah(1x19)
or
Sam and Madison(2x17)
over a year ago 67impala said…
Sam and Sarah - They were just so cute together!!

lol, fanfly! Payback for making me choose between YED John and YED Samuel!

Samantha Ferris as Ellen
or
Traci Dinwiddie as Pamela
over a year ago salemslot said…
big smile
Traci Dinwiddie as Pamela-What a cool character and she nailed the role with her performance

Mordecai
or
the barber in Provenance(I can't remember his name)
over a year ago linalin said…
Mordecai.

Dean's hallucinations in "Yellow Fever"
or
Dean's ability to see Demons before going to Hell.
over a year ago toti8 said…
Dean's ability to see demons before going to Hell -it was creepy!

Dean taking care of Sam and protecting him
or
John taking care of the boys (in his own way)
over a year ago Dean-girlx said…
although I love both .. Dean taking care of Sam and protecting.

new!Ruby [GC]
or
Bela
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago bela2 said…
laugh
new ruby

Dean running from a tiny dog in "yellow fever"
or
Dean running from hell hounds (his dream/nightmare) in "no rest for the wicked"
over a year ago Dean-girlx said…
Dean running from the tiny dog -- such an adorable scene! ♥♥ the hell hound scene was just sad =(

Dean and Castiel
or
Dean and Uriel
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago 67impala said…
Dean and Castiel! But he sure came out with some good ones to Uriel - "junkless" lol!

Pamela's psychic abilities
or
Chuck's prophesies
over a year ago fanfly said…
Pamela's psychic abilities- they were more versatile!

Grown Up Lilith
or
Little Girl Lilith
over a year ago 67impala said…
Definitely grown up Lilith - her little girl persona is freaky, but hard to relate to

The Supernatural books
or
The Ghostfacers' live-action video (3x13)
over a year ago fanfly said…
Oh nooooooo!!!!! How am I supposed to choose!? *eeny meeny miny mo*

the Supernatural books

Sam in that green and red western style shirt that he wore in 4x18
or
Sam in that white shirt with the faded red design (my fav of all his shirts; he's worn it several times- in Metamorphosis and a Very SPN Xmas etc)
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago 67impala said…
White shirt with faded red design - I love that one too! However, I did NOT love that red and green one, bleahh.

Dean having his cheeseburger taken away
or
Sam forgetting Dean's pie
over a year ago fanfly said…
Sam forgetting Dean's pie (so funny!- Dude, where's the pie?)

"Dean" hiding Sam's laptop(Tall Tales)
or
"Sam" letting the air out of the car's tires(Tall Tales)
over a year ago Dean-girlx said…
tongue
"Dean" hiding Sam's laptop. I felt bad for the poor Impala!! =( haha.

Dean in his black t-shirt
or
Dean in his brown leather jacket.
over a year ago winchester35 said…
cool
dean in his brown leather jacket, for sure!


dean as a demon .
or
sam as a demon.
over a year ago 67impala said…
Sam as a demon. I don't think Dean has ever been one, ;)

Dean's love of:

"Magic Fingers"
or
"Busty Asian Beauties"
over a year ago Dean-girlx said…
haha! both are awesome but I have to go with "magic fingers"! ♥

young!Mary
or
older!Mary

over a year ago 67impala said…
Aagghh! Can't I say both? :D Okay....

older!Mary

Mark and his snakes in "Yellow Fever"
or
Matt and his bugs in "Bugs"
over a year ago linalin said…
Mark and his snakes, I thought he was adorable, actually!

Sam in Yellow Fever
or
Sam in Bad day at Black Rock
over a year ago fanfly said…
Sam in Bad Day at Black Rock "I lost my shoe" (I thought he was kinda snotty in Yellow Fever)

Dean in Yellow Fever
or
Dean in Bad Day at Black Rock
over a year ago Dean-girlx said…
Dean in Bad Day at Black Rock :]]

young!John
or
older!John
over a year ago Sil2Y5 said…
older!John

The boys in normal clothes

or

The boys in suits
over a year ago linalin said…
Boys in normal clothes

Sam in janitor
or
Dean in electrician
over a year ago fanfly said…
Dean in electrician (even Sam couldn't make the janitor outfit sexy :PPP)

Sam in Scarecrow
or
Sam in Faith
over a year ago ghostgal said…
Sam in Scarecrow - loved him in that ep!

Bartender Jo
or
Hunter Jo
over a year ago Dean-girlx said…
Hunter Jo! ♥

crying!Bela
or
crying!young!Mary
over a year ago fanfly said…
You're kidding right? ;D crying!young!Mary of course!

Young!Mary in "In the Beginning"
or
Mom!Mary in "What Is and What Should Never Be"
over a year ago linalin said…
Young!Mary in "What is and What Should Never Be", because she was real, the one from the dream... not so much!

Young John, the mechanic
or
Old John, the hunter
over a year ago 67impala said…
No contest here, linalin! Old!Sexy!John, the hottt hunter!

The seasonal episodes:

"It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester"
or
"A Very Supernatural Christmas"
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago fanfly said…
Oh evil, just evil, making me choose *mutter grumble*

A Very Supernatural Christmas- I loved the flashbacks and their simple gifts at the end. It's the best Christmas episode of any show, ever.

Tammi (demon in Malleus Maleficarum)
or
Casey (demon in Sin City)
over a year ago linalin said…
Casey, I liked her... and she had some awesome chemistry with Dean

Shapeshifter Dean morphing
or
Dean post-Hell checking himself in the mirror
over a year ago fanfly said…
Shapeshifter Dean morphing for the awesome effect- I think that's the best "shifting" scene ever. I love how his teeth and nails pop out.
Dean post-Hell checking himself for the HOTNESS. Couldn't he have stared just a little longer?
Yes- I cheated. :PP

Angsty fan videos
or
Funny fan videos
over a year ago 67impala said…
Oh, you give me an evil one right back! Hmmmm.......

I'll go with angsty. Nothing like a good emotional wringing out every now and then!

Sam giving Dean the amulet in A Very Supernatural Christmas
or
Sam giving back Dean's amulet in Lazarus Rising
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago fanfly said…
Eeeeeeeevil!!!!!!!!!!

I'll go with the Christmas one just because I was so thrilled to see that it was Sam who gave Dean that amulet(I'd always wondered!) But of course Sam giving it back was so beautiful too.

Sam engaged to Jessica in WIAWSNB
or
Sam dis-engaged from Madison in IATL
over a year ago Dean-girlx said…
hah! Sam dis-engaged from Madison in IATL! [I don't know why but I HATE the idea of Sam/Jess]

Dean and his past relationship with Cassie [Route 666]
or
Dean and his relationship with Carmen [WIAWSNB]
over a year ago tinkymel said…
big smile
Sam's hair in Season 4 (I like longer hair)

Greesey Chille Cheese Fries
Or
Tofu Burger
over a year ago 67impala said…
Dean-girlx's first:
Dean and his relationship with Carmen. I loved them together!

Oops! You forgot to go to the current page, tinkymel, ;)) But I'd go with the greasy, Chili Cheese Fries, just minus the chili!

Sam visiting Jess's grave in Wendigo (in a dream)
or
Dean visiting John's grave in WIAWSNB (in the wish 'verse)
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago spn4eva said…
Dean visiting John's grave in WIAWSNB (in the wish)

I cried so much at that lol

Dean torchering Alistair
OR
Sam killing Alistair
???
over a year ago Dean-girlx said…
ugh! that's a hard one! Dean torturing Alistair - it was twisted and oh so hot! =P

Jo telling Dean to just leave. [no exit - 2x06]
or
Jo knowing that Dean won't call her. [BUABS - 2x14]

over a year ago tinkymel said…
big smile
Jo knowing Dean won't call her. That girl was a smart one.

Tuedsay
or
Wednesday
over a year ago spn4eva said…
Tuesday

The new Winchester brother been fake/trickster etc.
OR
The new Winchester brother been their actual brother.
over a year ago Dean-girlx said…
The new Winchester brother being their actutal brother - now before you all freak out and go all "but it's ONLY SUPPOSED TO BE Sam'n'Dean!!" I KNOW .. but I figure as long as the kid doesn't go with them [hunting] .. it'll be kind of cute to see Dean and Sam take care of him :] i'm looking forward to it, actually. even if he isn't their real brother.

Jensen
or
Jared
last edited over a year ago
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!