Supernatural

Supernatural This or That Game (Winchester Variety).

linalin posted on Mar 03, 2009 at 04:35PM
Found this game in Supernaturalfanwiki, and you must give two choices- Supernatural related- and the respondent must choose their favorite, then present two of their own.

I'll go with:

Dean's sawed-off
or
Sam's Colt

Supernatural 427 replies

Click here to write a response...

Showing Replies 51-100 of 427

over a year ago linalin said…
I was hoping someone would choose Possessed John, Daddy Winchester's body and the YED's personality... awesome mix, hehe.

I'll choose DemonDean, you know how I feel about shifters!!

Emotional Bobby
or
ConMan Bobby
over a year ago fanfly said…
ConMan Bobby!

CollegeBoy Sam
or
DarkSide Sam
over a year ago linalin said…
DarkSide Sam, he's so much sexier...

Season 1 Dean
or
Season 4 Dean
over a year ago fanfly said…
Season 4 Dean (although I'm an all season Dean girl, I'm a firm believer that characters should never tread water- one of the reasons that I like DarkSide Sam better than CollegBoy Sam)

Reaper
or
Demon

over a year ago linalin said…
Reaper... they are about so much more than just good or bad.

Dean + Sunglasses
or
Dean - Shirt
over a year ago 67impala said…
cool
Dean in sunglasses - ONLY sunglasses, ha,ha!

Snarky Dean
or
Sincere Dean
over a year ago fanfly said…
Tough one- seriously, they're pretty even with me so I'm just gonna pick randomly- eeny meeny miny mo!
Sincere Dean!

Alastair's death
or
Uriel's death
over a year ago Dean-girlx said…
Uriel's =D ♥ teehee.

Sam and his demon blood.
or
Dean and his destiny with the apocalypse. [I can't word that right, lol, hope you know what I mean!]
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago bela2 said…
hmmm
I love Dean but personally i'd have to go for Sam and his demon blood!

Trickser
or
vengeful spirit
over a year ago fanfly said…
Trickster! I ❤ the Trickster!

Death Takes A Holiday
or
On the Head of a Pin

over a year ago linalin said…
On the Head of a Pin, it gave us me even more jaw separation time than Death Takes a Holiday.

Torturer Dean
or
Demonically Pumped Torturer Sam
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago Dean-girlx said…
Tortuer Dean! ♥

Alistair being tortured
or
Alistair torturing.
over a year ago linalin said…
Alistair being tortured, I liked that.

Dean, The Brother
or
Dean, The Son
over a year ago Dean-girlx said…
ohh! hard choice .. hmm.

Dean, the brother.

drunk!Sam
or
mad!Sam
over a year ago toti8 said…
angry
mad!Sam -I loved it when he was furious in Death Takes A Holiday and said firmly :''You have no idea!''

The first Ghostfacers' episode
or
The second Ghostfacers' episode
over a year ago Dean-girlx said…
the first episode :]

Sam shooting Dean with rocksalt [Asylum - season one]
or
Dean almost chopping Sam's head off with an axe [Sex & Violence - season four]
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago bela2 said…
laugh
Difficult choice! um i'm gonna have to go with Sam shooting Dean with rocksalt if only for the "no...but it'll hurt like hell" line.

"Tall tales"
or
"Mystery spot"
over a year ago linalin said…
Oh baby! Hard pick, I love all Trickster episodes... but I'll go with Mystery Spot.

Dean hitting on chicks
or
Dean getting hit on by chicks
over a year ago Dean-girlx said…
Dean hitting on chicks! =D ♥ teeheee :]]

Jessica
or
Madison
over a year ago fanfly said…
Madison- I just had a better feel for her character. Jessica just didn't get enough screen time.

Anna
or
Ruby
over a year ago toti8 said…
Oh I can't choose because both are annoying!If I really had to pick one it would be Ruby.

Meg
or
Uriel
over a year ago fanfly said…
Uriel

Uriel
or
Alastair
over a year ago 67impala said…
Alastair - maximum creepiness factor

Uriel's suit and tie
or
Castiel's rumpled trench coat
over a year ago linalin said…
Uriel's suit and tie, that was one pimped out angel!

Sam's version of Dean in Tall Tales
or
Dean's version of Sam in Tall Tales
over a year ago Kaidi said…
Sam's version of Dean :)

Sam as Bikini Inspector (Something Wicked)
or
Sam as Priest (Nightmare)
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago bela2 said…
kiss
Definatly sam as bikini inspector!

Dean's fear of flying
or
Sam's fear of clowns
over a year ago Dean-girlx said…
Dean's fear of flying.

Sam forgetting the pie.
or
Dean paying the demon for the pie in the diner.
over a year ago 67impala said…
Sam forgetting the pie!

Dean in those red shorts
or
Dean in sleep pants
over a year ago samsgirl84 said…
heart
Dean in Sleep Pants! Hott!!!

Sam & Dean's Credit Card Fraud
or
Hustling Pool and Poker.
over a year ago fanfly said…
Hustling- so funny.

Mark Rolston's Alastair(Heaven and Hell)
or
Christopher Heyerdahl's Alastair(On the Head of a Pin)
over a year ago Dean-girlx said…
ohh man! I liked both of them buuuuut I think I liked Mark Rolston as Alastair a bit better.

Anna kicking ass
or
Castiel getting his ass kicked
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago fanfly said…
Anna kicking ass- I love her. Cas is such a wuss, seriously.

On the Head of a Pin
or
Death Takes a Holiday
over a year ago 67impala said…
On the Head of a Pin - already one of my favourites!

Ruby's demon-killing knife
or
Anna's angel-killing sword
over a year ago Kaidi said…
Ruby's demon-killing knife. :)

Ed
or
Harry
over a year ago fanfly said…
Ed! lol

Speaking of Ghostfacers....
Maggie
or
Spruce
over a year ago linalin said…
Spruce!! Maggie is so beggin' it!

Dean's comb-over
or
Sam's geek-boy uniform
over a year ago Dean-girlx said…
Dean's comb-over.

ghost boy in 4x15
or
invisible boy in 4x08
over a year ago linalin said…
ghost boy, invisible boy was such a neek!

Winchesters
or
Campbells
over a year ago Dean-girlx said…
heart
Winchesters!! =D ♥♥♥♥

Dean driving the impala
or
Sam driving the impala
over a year ago fanfly said…
Dean driving it!

Samuel Campbell
or
Deanna Campbell
over a year ago 67impala said…
Samuel Campbell I mean, Mitch Pileggi!

The house in "Family Remains"
or
The apartment building in "No Exit"
over a year ago Kaidi said…
The apartment building in "No Exit"

"I hope your apple pie was freakin' worth it"
or
"Driver picks the music. Shotgun shuts his cakehole"
over a year ago linalin said…
"Driver picks the music, shotgun shuts his cakehole." that's a classic!

Boyfriend Sam
or
Sexy Sam
over a year ago 67impala said…
Ha,ha! Is there even a contest here?

SEXY SAM!!

Bad-boy Dean
or
Hunter Dean
over a year ago linalin said…
hehe, Hunter Dean, bad-boy Dean sometimes comes out goofy and makes me laugh, hunter Dean is bloody sexy.

Sam's Pumas
or
Sam's Boots
over a year ago Kaidi said…
Sam's Boots

OK, now really crazy one...

Jared as Dean
or
Jensen as Sam
over a year ago linalin said…
heheh, Jensen as Sam, somehow, I think he'd have made it as believable as he makes Dean appear.

Jeffrey as Bobby
or
Jim as John
over a year ago Dean-girlx said…
Jeffrey as Bobby! :] ♥

Uriel breaking the devils trap in OTHOAP.
or
Meg [in Sam's body] breaking the devils trap in BUABS.
over a year ago linalin said…
Meg, she was less sly about that, and Sam was so sexy!

Sam, the Fed
or
Dean, the Fed
over a year ago 67impala said…
Dean the Fed. Sam looks too cute to be a Fed!

Father Sam
or
Gym teacher Dean
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!