Only ONE person can have their vote counted for the winner of each round. So in order to have your vote count you have the best or most convincing comment, which included videos or famous saying. NO links older then 1 year are counted.The best explanation gets their vote counted, so have fun

FYI, this is for FUN, so no swearing at one another but debating is fine. If you want you can place a comment on who you think had the best comment.

Taeyeon- best singer

Jessica- she is pretty, models, and can sing well

Sunny- she being more popular outside of SNSD then in it, brings more attention to the group without having to sing and dance

Tiffany: i think she is the next because she isn't good at anything beside singing and even then she uses alot of assistance when she sings adn sucks at dancing. She has little likeability beside her just being pretty
Latest dance:link

TTS live, you can see she uses assistance:link

Hyoyeon- she dance well and her appearances on variety shows helps helps bring press to the group

Sooyoung- she is a well rounded character she is more use then useless sometimes

Seohyun- she has a great voice, can dance, and a good role model

well, i know she won't leave for the next few rounds, so what's the point of explaining? i can say that she doesn't add anything to the group but most of you don't think the same

i honeslty don't understand why Tiffany? she has a pretty good voice, in fact i think she has the second best voice and she's pretty stable on live performances...the only negative thing is the fact that she's not the best dancer
but people are forgetting the fact that she's the best english speaker? yeah, Jessica is good too, but comme on...Tiffany basically makes all the english speeches. when we hear jessica, we notice that she still needs to think a little before talking. the same for Sooyoung
Tiffany is also a pretty good model, she's appearing more and more on magazines...and she did a decent job as an actress on her musical

i mean, if you guys compare Tiffany to Hyoyeon or Sunny, do you really think that they're more talented than her, overall?

you guys are only thinking about singing and dancing, that's it...well, let's just say it's not fair

^"Tiffany to Hyoyeon or Sunny, do you really think that they're more talented than her, overall" oh yeah :P. Dude no need to cry I mean you make a good point but this girl is only useful because she is pretty. Her voice is not good live, she sucks at dancing, and she adds nothing to the group but another pretty member. Jessica can do all Tiffany does and better, singing, dancing, acting, and modeling. Why Sunny?

Do you mean least talented or actually useless? Because Yoona brings in a lot of fans and Yuri is the sexy one, meaning they're both very useful.

^" have been wondering since this is a large group of people is there anyone who is just "extra". I mean they all can sing and dance but is there anything else these girls can do besides that, if not who can't. I want to know which member is the most useless (doesn't add anything special to the group) to the most useful (add alot to the group). Explain why and not just for the one you voted for but for ALL of them.

Only ONE person can have thier vote counted for the winner of each round. So in order to have your vote count you have the best or most convincing comment, which included videos or famous saying. NO links older then 1 year are counted.The best explanation gets their vote counted, so have fun "

SugarBell20 well, if you say that Tiffany doesn't add anything, what about Sunny? she's not the best singer or dancer, either...and she doesn't stand out for anything. people only started to notice her when she cut her hair, let's be honest

"Jessica can do all Tiffany does and better, singing, dancing, acting, and modeling" that's your opinion. i think Tiffany is a much better singer, actress and model...don't know about dancing, cause, like i said, i can't see much difference between Fany, Sica and Sunny's dancing...
Jessica is a terrible actress. her acting was pretty painful to watch

^I think I mentioned Sunny in my comment "she being more popular outside of SNSD then in it, brings more attention to the group without having to sing and dance" she MC solo and got a nomination for her musical.

I asked again why you voted for Sunny because to me she has more accomplishments than Tiffany as far as merit and talent go, she just isn't very pretty, but I wanted your opinion. I think people starting thinking Sunny was "pretty" after her haircut not that she was "useful" but ok.

Acting and modeling I will give you on wither it can be based opinion, but singing and dancing we all know Jessica is better.

Pretty_angel92, can you provide links and proof for all the members in order for your vote to count?

I think Hyoyeon should be the next one to be left out. She's a brilliant dancer but her style (powerful, hiphop-oriented) doesn't really suit SNSD's style (elegant, womanly). Plus she doesn't contribute much (or may I say, anything) to their singing. I'm sure they will be just fine without her.

^if you want your vote to count please list all the members and why Hyoyeon is the one you voted for and provide a link.

I dont know why you guys choose Tiffany or Sunny. I personally find their voice a lot more memorable than Taeyeon's and Jessica's. If I can bring the group number down to 5, it should be Taeyeon, Jessica, Sooyoung, Sunny, Tiffany. And to 3, it should be Jessica, Sooyoung, Sunny/or/Tiffany (at this point Taeyeon is better off going solo).

^now all you need is a link

Tiffany , she is #4 in singing . and #9 in dancing.

^you need to talk about all the members and provide a link if you want your vote to count.

She may be the best dancer but she is in music industry

Taeyeon - Best singer in SNSD , leader

Jessica - Great Singer , SNSD Need her because her great voice.

Seohyun - She is the most talented in SNSD , She have a nice voice and can dance well . She is #5 in dancing.seohyun also helps in dance battle link . She can play piano and she use many language and she is good in english too ^^ So maybe sometimes she can replace Soo , Fany , Sica :D

Hyoyeon - She is Main Dancer , SNSD need her . she is not useless . And she sings well too ^^

Sunny - Sooyoung is more useless than Sunny because Sunny better in singing and about dancing , Soo in #4 Sunny in #6, not really far.

Sooyoung - Like @SugarBell92 said "she is more use then useless sometimes" at least she is not really useless because she is #4 in dancing and she is #6 in singing after sunny.Sooyoung is really good in singing she should get more part than HyoYoonYul. She have a nice voice ^^ i like her voice more than her dancing :D link

Tiffany - She is bad in dancing and she is #4 in singing , but Sunny is more useful than her because Sunny can sing well and dance well.But Tiffany? Just good in singing.

^ actually, there's some diferences on SM's new ranking
Sooyoung is 3rd at dancing and Sunny is 5th
Tiffany is 3rd at singing

@YushiGirl, can you be more detailed so your vote can count

pretty_angel92 , if you watch dance battle on tv , Smtown live in seoul etc , Always YoonYulHyo Not SooHyoYul :( that's mean Yoona is #3 Soo is #4 :(

who voted seohyun lol are u kinding lol

^can you give a full list of why for all the members and provide links.

ImanNessa99, that doesn't mean anything. maybe there was a reason why Sooyoung didn't make part of the dance...
but i've seen dance performances where Yoona isn't included, so yeah, it doesn't really mean anything

i'm just gonna use a basic example. Hyoyeon has almost no role in the Hoot MV.

link

Shiraz97 , Again sooyoung >< Can you tell me why?
And i know maybe you hate Soo but not because of this you choose her as the ugliest,useless and etc.

I just picked one because I didn't know who to choose.... I think everyone in SNSD is useful in SNSD. Like they say: They only shine when all 9 girls are on the stage together <3 :D I also think so :D But if I had to choose I would choose Jessica because I think she would be as popular as now even if she was alone :D The same goes for Taeyeon and Tiffany because they sing well and they also can dance :D But as for Hyoyeon she can't only be famous for her amazing dancing, she would be better within a group such as SNSD :D Hyoyeon is of course very talented and I love her soooo much! <3 but I chose Jessica because she could be good alone as well as in a group :D

^can you list why not all the other member and provide a link, then your vote would count

i dont really get why Tiffany and Hyoyeon are in the top 3. Tiffany is a great singer- one of the top 3- and Hyoyeon is the best dancer+ she super funny. Sooyoung isnt the best singer or dancer and she isnt really funny thats y i choose her

^can you make full list of why not for EACH member and provide a link why you say Sooyoung.

@anime-lover211 , Sooyoung is the best singer after sunny^^ and she is really funny.I can accept if you picked Sooyoung.But i cant accept for the reason.

Winner of poll is ImanNessa99 who voted for Tiffany. New poll tommorow