answer this question

The Hunger Games Question

Who else agrees with me that if you didn't read the book you couldn't really enjoy the movie as much?

 MikkiDs posted over a year ago
next question »

The Hunger Games Answers

KatnissAndea16 said:
Yeah, I agree.. Cause people who didn't read the book don't really seem to understand Katniss' point of view in that particular scene. I know that because my family and friends keep on asking me about what is gonna happen next, or even just a simple thing like who is that and what is she doing...
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
xElvenPiratex said:

I both agree and disagree.

As a fan of the books, I was really looking forward to the film and seeing the things I'd pictured in my head for so long come to life. For that reason, I was completely psyched about seeing it and geeked out the entire time I was at the theater.

However, the fact that I am such a fan of the books also hindered my enjoyment of the film because I was so busy comparing it to the book in my head, I couldn't help but be disappointed that certain things were left out (the Avox girl, for example). I almost wished that I hadn't read the book yet, so that I could simply enjoy the movie and not constantly be comparing it to the books.

So while I think that people who haven't read the books are definitely missing out, I also envy them a bit, because they can enjoy the movie for what it is without feeling like something's missing.


select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
CuPcAkE124 said:
Me!! When I went to see it, I went with a group of friends. Two of them hadn't read any of the books. (I couldn't believe it!! Haha) anyway, I ended up having to sit between them, and every two minutes they would ask stuff like, "Who is that?" or "What does that mean?" I, on the other hand, knew exactly what was happening because I could remember that part clearly from the book and remember her emotions at that point. For someone who had not read the books, this would be a hard movie to follow, Espesially sense the concept (you know, after the fall of The US, and how kids kill other kids...) is so hard to grasp. I do think that the movie was meant for the fans of the book, not some lazy person who just watches the movie. (no offence to anyone who just saw the movie) To me, movies from books are truely for the readers to see the book through different eyes, to interpret it in a whole new way, to SEE the words come to life, and I think the Hunger Games movie did that fairly well. I don't suggest seeing the movie before the book, because you won't really be able to follow it, and it's kind of hard to understand.

<3 y'all
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
"remember her emotions" HER being Katniss. Sorry:)
CuPcAkE124 posted over a year ago
gingermycat said:
yeah i agree,i havent seen the movie-seeing it soon-but read the books and was told that they didnt include everything
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
JamesMalsow said:
me 2
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
hollistergurl said:
Yeah, maybe.. I guess it depends on the type of person. But yeah, if you know the whole storyline and the movie turns out to be different, it could upset you.
But the movie was pretty great with the plot so I liked it, even though it missed a few things.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
canddfan29 said:
Moi! It wasn't as detailed as the book and there was so much more romance in the book.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »