Supernatural Imagine if...

befferz posted on Aug 10, 2010 at 11:54AM
What do you think would happen, in the given scenarios. Look at the reply above and write what you think. Then post your own scenario.

Round 1 - Imagine if sam died and could never come back
last edited on Nov 10, 2010 at 08:13PM

Supernatural 90 replies

Click here to write a response...
Previous

Showing Replies 1-50 of 90

over a year ago shomill said…
Haha, don't delete it just cuz no one posted. Some games take time to pick up speed.

I think Dean would spend the rest of his life looking for a way to bring Sam back, and in the meantime, he'd bury himself in his work. Remember Sam in the heartbreaking scene in Mystery Spot, six months after Dean died? I think Dean'd be just like that.

We'll get a chance to see something like that on 9/24! Yay!!!

Ok, um...
Imagine if Dean turned down a bacon cheeseburger and pie.
over a year ago Magy25 said…
smile
Post a pick telling about this game. I think it's funny, maybe other people just don't know it exists, yet!

We all should be concerned!!

Imagine if Dean wore shorts all the time.
over a year ago angel333 said…
heart
wouldnt bother me, im a SAM girl all the way haha :D


now imagine if sam was shirtless for a whole episode :D
over a year ago Magy25 said…
hmmm
*sigh* I wouldn't even blink!

Imagine if... I guess I blocked with shirtless Sam LOL

Imagine if Cas walked in while Dean was with a girl
over a year ago befferz said…
mischievous
How would I post a pick about it, like a link or in the wall...

Then I'd just burst out laughing, cause cas would do that thing he does when he's really confused and feels awkward

imagine if, cas turned phyco angel and went on a killing rampage and killed Sam and dean
over a year ago shomill said…
You could ask a question like "New game, called Imagine if...", and copy and paste the link for this forum in the comments.

In answer to beff's: yikes!!!! I'd scream, cry, and find a good angel psychiatric facility.

*btw, shirtless Sam, yum!!!!

Ok, imagine if the boys had a case in Hawaii rescuing surfer girls.
over a year ago angel333 said…
laugh
aww pity they would have to be shirtless :D i just hope the camera hads alot of fully body shots :D and i would most likely die after the ep hahha

imagine if... Dean turned out to be gay... with ash haha(sorry i had to say it)
over a year ago pizzapi said…
with ash ? that would actually be... kinda hot !

imagine if sam had the bad luck from bad day at black rock forever ! guy. can. not. hold onto a pair of shoes !
over a year ago Magy25 said…
Ahahah, poor Sammy. I think Dean would find a way to get Sam back to normal again :)

Imagine if Sam found Ruby in hell.
over a year ago shomill said…
Um... wow. Good one. Um... I think he's still pissed at her and there'd be a huge fight. Sam might even take pleasure in torturing her. *evil grin*

Imagine if Lisa finally admitted that Ben is Dean's son.
over a year ago angel333 said…
id be kinda aww moment, but what would happen when he travells around again?? hed be worried about him alot

imagine if...
the killed bobby off in the 4 episode (6th season)
over a year ago befferz said…
nice response to the ruby one. Torture. That's awesome, I really really hate ruby

Sam an dean would be pretty messed up, cause he's like a father figure, and they'ed become obbsessed with finding the thin. That killed them.

Imagine if somehow jo came back from he'll, but she was now a demon.
over a year ago angel333 said…
big smile
mmm i just dont think jo would got to hell, but if she was a demon id be sad, she was a good female character that wasnt all mushy and stuff haha

imagine if... jessica didnt actually die, and she came back with a child ( i just thought id put it out there)
over a year ago Magy25 said…
Sam would be every happy for her being alive and pissed 'cause she didn't say she was alive and confused cause he had a child he had never met.~

Imagine if Bobby become an angel
over a year ago angel333 said…
that be kinda cool, but i dont think he'd be good at taking orders, hahaha cas might get pissed with him lol :D


imagine if ... sam didnt want to hunt with his brother :(
over a year ago shawshank393 said…
He'd go back to College and the show would turn into a 90210 clone..

Imagine if the boys were up against the Lost Boys...
over a year ago angel333 said…
smile
omg i love that movie!!! :D haha i just hope they get them in time hahaha

imagine if... sam and dean had a sister
over a year ago HorrorFan101 said…
it would be me :) lol actually then i wouldn't get the boys.... :/ tricky one.... :/

imagine if there was going to be no season 6 and swan song was how the show finished
over a year ago jodith said…
i'll go like : OMG NOOOOOOOOOOOO sam cant die.dean cant be with lisa NOOOOOOOOO<< which means i'll go crazy and plan to kill Eric kripke myself!

Imagine if the YED returns for SPN S6!!<"they're alredy
sayiN'it"!!?

P-S: i totally love the game xD
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago tinzn92 said…
huh... I..uuuh,I would call Kripke or Gamble and DEMAND a S6!

Imagine if Dean started a singing, as his career.
over a year ago tinzn92 said…
oopps, didn't see that you(jodith) had answerd HorrorFan101's xD
over a year ago Magy25 said…
smile
He would have success, maybe not only for his voice, but...

Imagine if Sam found out he had a seven year old daughter he didn't know about
over a year ago angel333 said…
big smile
awww it would be sweet, but i think he would worry about her. i think it would be cool


imagine if... ash, jo and ellen came back
over a year ago Magy25 said…
That would be awsome. I loved them.

Imagine if Sarah come back.
over a year ago HorrorFan101 said…
Yay!! Team Sam and Sarah!! I watched that episode today! How weird? <3 Love it though :)

Imagine if Dean was part demon not Sam :S
over a year ago jodith said…
Holly shit dont dont you go throw it at my Dean! lol xD
i think it would be Fine with me! as long as he dont go Dark saide!!

imagin if Castiel killed Sam!! >Random? i know but the game is all about imagination xD
over a year ago befferz said…
Your right, good question... Yay there's a second page

even though I love cas, I'd probably hate him, no one kills Sam.

Imagine if cas got killed and couldn't come back
over a year ago angel333 said…
id be sad but get over it, im a sam girl all the way
over a year ago shomill said…
^Same here.

What's all this about Sam having a kid? Did I miss some spoilers somewhere???

Imagine if Dean was gay. (throw your imagination in high gear!)
over a year ago angel333 said…
heart
haha na u didnt miss anything, i think every 1 saying it because people think ben is dean son , so yer.

wouldnt bother me one bit, i just hope its not wincest (or wat ever they call it ugh)

imagine if... they made a 7th season
over a year ago befferz said…
then i'd invite everyone round to mine, and we'd have a SPN S7 party, i can see it now.

imagine if it turned out lisa was married or had a boyfriend. what would dean do.?
over a year ago angel333 said…
i think he'd be sad and a little jealouse but he'd want wats best for ben. and i think he would do all sorts of stuff to make sure e's not a demon haha

imagine if...sam wasnt dean brother, he wouldbe adopted
over a year ago shomill said…
Whoah!!! You're evil, you know that? Sam and Dean would be so upset, they'd feel sorry for themselves, get into some huge fight over some little thing that doesn't matter, split up, and get themselves into huge trouble. Neither one would be sober for a long time. Then, when one or both of them is about ready to get himself killed, the other would come to his rescue, they'd hug (I hope!) and make up, and be "Hey, man, it doesn't matter. You're still my brother."

Imagine if John and Mary and Jess all came back from the dead.
over a year ago angel333 said…
haha im only have evil :D

and it be cool, tho it be weird with john and mary coming back, i think sam would get back with jess tho. i think every one would be happy, but be worried about each other to much.

imagine if... dean was the one on demon blood.
over a year ago Magy25 said…
uhh, that's difficult.

I think that he would have done the same that Sam did, maybe not be addicted to deamon blood, but I think he would have let Lucifer in as well.

Imagine if Sam and Gordon (pretending he was still alive!) become best friends.
over a year ago shomill said…
Oh, come ON!!! THAT would never happen!
over a year ago Magy25 said…
kiss
I know, but that's why it's imagine if!

Ok, so, imagine if Lisa started hunting with the brothers
over a year ago befferz said…
They'ed ditch her after a while, cause shed want to keep ben safe.

What if cas never cam back from heaven in S6
over a year ago angel333 said…
aww id be sad, but then again it would go back to how it was in the first couple seasons.

imagine if... sam became an angel
over a year ago jodith said…
smile
No No No sure i love Angels but i like sam more as A HUNTER nothing more nothing less xD

imagine if..zacharia came back 4 season 6 ?!
over a year ago shomill said…
I'd puke.

Imagine if Bela became the next Crossroads Demon.
over a year ago Magy25 said…
smile
That would be interesting, Bela dealing with Sam or Dean.

Imagine if Cas and Dean changed bodies.
over a year ago joose32 said…
laugh
That would be funny and I think Dean would probably lose Cas' virginity for him XD

Imagine if Sam was infected with ghost sickness
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago sarahshiner said…
It would be fun. Imagine two brothers embrace each other terrified from the drop-down gloom.

imagine if Dean's favourite band was Jonas Brothers xD
over a year ago befferz said…
If that happened, i'd suddenly pretend the jonas brothers were awesome, but secretly lose faith in deans music taste. METALLICA RULES!!!!!

What if dean decided to give up the Metallicar and got a new car
over a year ago sarahshiner said…
He'll realize that he is in paralel univers and then start looking for his beloved car.

Imagine if Castiel was lying to the boys all the time and he was secretly on the bad side.
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago angel333 said…
ohhh sam and dean would be pissed, i think they might try to hunt him but have some difficulty

imagine if... jess came back and hooked up with dean instead of sam
over a year ago sarahshiner said…
Dean will be like "Get off me, bitch! You hurt my brother's feelings." And then kill her. xD

imagine if Sam wasn't played by Jared Padalecki. [god, save us from this!]
over a year ago Magy25 said…
I can't imagine anyone else playing Sam.

Imagine if Dean offered the Metalicar to Sam
over a year ago jodith said…
Whaaaaaaaaaat?? i so wont Agree ofcourse sam can ride it whenever he want as long as its Dean's Metalicar,,sorry sam but the Impala belongs to Dean< ok i've put the wrong way,,but i like it 4 Dean more then Sam!!

Imagine if ruby didnt die and she was Pregnant!! "sam's baby"