So here's how it works: every week, I make a pick for an episode. You guys rate it, 1-10, and I'll take the average and post it here. When we're done, we'll see which episodes are the REAL fan favorites! Episodes will be listed in order of their ratings, highest to lowest.

I'll also make articles showing the ratings for each season.

Season 1
Pilot: 9.37
Shadow: 9.29
Faith: 9.01
Home: 8.96
Scarecrow: 8.45
Phantom Traveler: 8.34
Dead in the Water: 8.25
Bloody Mary: 8.07
Nightmare: 7.96
Skin: 7.95
Asylum: 7.81
Hook Man: 7.27
Wendigo: 6.97
Route 666: 6.17
Bugs: 5.52
Hell House: