Supernatural Question

Hook Man discrepancy. Anyone else think of this? (Please read description.)

If they only needed to melt the Hook Man's hook to destroy it, why wasn't he destroyed when the hook was melted down and reforged back in 1862?

oh. i see your point. :S hmmm xxx

HorrorFan101 posted over a year ago

shomill posted over a year ago

next question »

Puppyslove said:

Did it have to be salted, too? I can't remember if Dean had put salt on the fire they were using?

posted over a year ago

Huh. I don't remember seeing him salt the fire, but maybe that's something we just didn't see. Nice one! *thumbs up*

shomill posted over a year ago

because he wasn't clinging to anyones emotions back then?

Dean-girlx posted over a year ago

AND part of the hook was still around. only in necklace form. When Dean melted it down, it was gone.

Dean-girlx posted over a year ago

next question »