Sword Art Online.
There's more sci-fi fantasy anime out there, it's not the single most best anime and anyone who disagrees with you isn't a hater, and Kirito is NOT the best anime swordsman. (seriously, just because you can kill a few dragons in Skyrim doesn't mean you could stand a chance against a dragon in real life)
Get over it, people.
(I started watching it when it aired on Toonami but got bored of it because it seemed to just repeat itself)
Tokyo Ghoul. I love horror, so I thought I'd like this. I like some of the characters, but I failed to see any personality in Kaneki. Also, season 2 is a damn mess. I know that a LOT of people are going to hate me for this, but, you know... I don't care
Personally, the show was a bit too hyped for me. Don't get me wrong, I love it. But it is a bit overrated and you're right that the second season was all over the place. Kaneki was in there for a total of minutes that racked up to one single episode in the whole season.
Re:Zero
The hype around this show was unreal. It wasn't an awful show, but it could have gone so many places with its plot that it didn't and fell short of the potential it could have had. Not to mention some things dragged on way too long and thr fight scenes were pretty...bad. ..
Overall not worth the huge hype it had even if it was an okay show.
As much as I love Attack on Titan, it didn't quiet live up to the expectation. Yes, the animation is amazing, I easily binged all the episodes, and the story is great but something about it just didn't feel like it fit the expectation I was holding it too. Then I read the manga and thought to myself "THIS is what the hype was."
Plus I never expected Eren to be the annoyingly edgy lil bitch he has a tendency to be.