answer this question

Random Question

Why are books better then the movies

Examples:
Mrs Frisby and the rats of Nimh
The secret of NIMH
The Twilight series
Twilight

Books are always better than the move in some peoples eyes if you disagree tell me why
 shadow378 posted over a year ago
next question »

Random Answers

CD-1 said:
the books r better because you interpret the book in your on way like for example if your making a movie of wht u read in your heard you may picture the characters differently then the movie or think they would sound differently etc.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Exactly!
Lisa02127kj posted over a year ago
*
Yes that's what I think too
shadow378 posted over a year ago
BlindBandit92 said:
The original media is A:WAYS better. Whether it's an anime,comic,video game,visual novel,manga,book,etc. It's always better. The movie may not have time to put in as much stuff as the original media or they may just fuck it up completely.

ONE GOOD EXAMPLE would be the X-men movies.

Rogue was not wimpy. She was a very powerful female character and my favorite in the X-men but they made her into a little lost child,clingy,whiny bitch. (No offense to the actress but I absolutely hated her character in the movies) Same thing with Storm, Iceman and many others. The one they got the most accurate was Wolverine.

And not to mention Spider-man-3. I hate that movie with a passion. Did not follow the comic book at all.

Tons of media are constantly adapted into movies and most of the time they absolutely suck. Jumper and Push books were supposedly better the movies. I heard Harry Potter books were better than the movies. IMO the original media is always better than the movies.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Awesome! And yes! I hated Rogue in the movies! Here: link
wantadog posted over a year ago
*
NIce! Thanks for the link^^
BlindBandit92 posted over a year ago
flippy_fan210 said:
because people never put enough details into the movies and they cut out some parts.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
wantadog said:
Because generally the books come first.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Panda-Hero said:
*facepalm*
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
girsmurf22 said:
No i dont disagree.

Ususally with some movies they will leave out some things that were in the book.

Like in the hunger games,if they had included everything tht was in the book in the movie,people said it would ave been rated R

So yeah i agree
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
i hate it when they do tht
CD-1 posted over a year ago
*
ikr
girsmurf22 posted over a year ago
Jeffersonian said:
It honestly depends on the book/movie but it's not always true...especially if they don't stray from the book too much.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
DmitryVladimir said:
Books are better than movies for your imagination will always be greatest.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
prussiaducky said:
MOVIES ALWAYS CRUSH MY IMAGINATION!!! D: like in certain scenes in books i think of it differently! But then they mess it up and i forget what it once looked like in my head D: like percy jackson totally messed up in the movie...i DIED when i watched tat terrible movie!!!!!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
DreamyMuffin said:
Books are better because they give more background than the movies do and you are able to use your imagine.Movies are there to give people a picture of what things are like and how it is.It makes it easier for people who don't use their imagination very well when it comes to reading...
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
*Imagination :P
DreamyMuffin posted over a year ago
Templarette said:
Because when you read books, you activate the most powerful thing in the world; your imagination. Plus, with books, there’s more room for assumptions and various interpretations; they make you think. Books enrich your vocabulary and knowledge as well. Books tell you things with more detail.

Movies give you an excuse to fall into a state of trance in front of an illuminated plastic-box with a bucket of popcorn between your legs. :P
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
.....I’m gonna be honest with you guys and admit that I’m more of a watcher than a reader. I *do* read, but not as much as I watch movies.
Templarette posted over a year ago
Immortal42 said:
I think that most of it is just because the book is the original. It's just like fanfiction will never be as good as the original.

Also, when reading, you can interpret everything for yourself. When watching the movie, it's all laid out for you and you're forced to picture things the way the producer pictured them.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
HeitsiTsegin said:
Movies made from popular books are often half assed when the writers know that they have to put their heart and soul into writing to even so much as get a book published.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
hgfan5602 said:
Because books are written by the actual person who had the actual inspiration. So basically, movies that are based on books tend to be a little less descriptive because 1) the person who directed the movie doesn't have the actual inspiration and 2) the movie obviously has to be shorter because it can't be as long as the book- so, parts are cut out.

And, I bet you mean the Hunger Games too.
select as best answer
Because books are written by the actual person who had the actual inspiration. So basically, movies that are based on books tend to be a little less descriptive because 1) the person who directed the movie doesn't have the actual inspiration and 2) the movie obviously has to be shorter because it can't be as long as the book- so, parts are cut out.

And, I bet you mean the Hunger Games too.
posted over a year ago 
wtp3 said:
Well i don't read books i just pretend to so i want get in big trouble and Movies are long like books well a little shorter but i dont like books

select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
dustfinger said:
They leave for opportunities for a reader's imagination to run through. Most Movie adaptations suck because the directors are in charge and they like to change things
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Zero_Delta said:
Authors put time and effort into the books, then Hollywood rushes in, takes the name, throws the movie together, and puts it into theaters to get their money as fast as possible.

Hollywood's just a bunch of greedy pigs.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
jester616 said:
Books are almost always better because of the greater insight you get into the characters' heads. There are also more details that movies just don't cover, if only because the movies would end up being hours and hours longer.

One glaring exception, in my opinion, is Jaws. The movie is just that good. The book has silly sub-plots that don't go anywhere, and the dialogue is flat.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »