They're two good looking Jews. It's natural.

Lame, but all I could think of.

"I knew it was more than a dream, it was a message from God: Rachel was a hot Jew and the good lord wanted me to get into her pants."

"Wanna make out?" / "Sure!"

"She can relate to Puck because they're going through the same thing and her guard is completey down and she can be honest with him." - Lea Michele

"It's grape. I know that's your favorite because the last time I threw a grape one in your face you licked your lips before you cleaned yourself off."

"Good times never seem so good..."

Six seems like a good number. I'm making the pick now! :)