this may sound stupid because im only on the 4th season...but when haley and nathan had that fight over birth control and she went back on it...well than HOW did she end up pregnant? i dont think it was that one time in season 3
Mark said that Haley got pregnant when she wasn't on birth control, yess, that one time she wasn't on birth control in season 3. Which was when they got back together. This one in the picture :)
