Of James' friends who do you think Lily was closest to?? Poll Results - Lily and James Potter

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Lily and James Potter Of James' friends who do you think Lily was closest to??

75 fans picked:

Remus

64%

Sirius

36%

Peter

no votes yet

TmoVie_obsessed posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

15 comments

	weaslyismyking picked Remus: Hard to say; she and Remus had more in common, and were friends even before James and Lily started dating... but I think after time, Lily would have become close to Sirius too. posted over a year ago.

	Cas_Cat_2 picked Sirius: Good question. =) I think it's Sirius, since he's Harry's godfather and James' best friend. <33 But she's also very close with Remus, of course. posted over a year ago.

	harryandsiriusx picked Sirius: Sirius. But her and Remus were good friends :) posted over a year ago.

	LoveFredW picked Sirius: I mean they both i think meant a lot to her too posted over a year ago.

	othobsessed92 picked Sirius: I think in the beginning she would have been really good friends with Remus, because he was the only serious Marauder, but I think once she became more open towards them, and started going out with James, she and Sirius got pretty close! I mean its hard to really know Sirius and not love him! But for the most part its a tough contest between both Sirius and Remus =) posted over a year ago.

	LifesGoodx3 picked Sirius: Or Remus... But I chose Sirius because Sirius is James best friend, so she probably saw him more. posted over a year ago.

	A-Gie picked Remus: Also Sirius. But I think that Lily was closer to Remus, because He said She never turned Her back on Him when She found out that He was a werewolf and She had the ability to see good sides in everyone. posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	devialy55 picked Sirius: dang thats hard posted over a year ago.

	HecateA picked Remus: A-Gie, that's what I was about to say. I think out of all the Marauders, Remus was the one she knew best, also perhaps respected or got along with. Especially if she was head-girl, him being head-boy... posted over a year ago.

	gr8hpfan picked Sirius: I think it'll be Sirius. It makes more sense, he was Harry's godfather, and the letter Harry found at Grimmauld place suggested that she was close to him. Well maybe even Remus, but yeah. posted over a year ago.

	jfren43 picked Sirius: sirius because he is harry's godfather and he knew james and lily posted over a year ago.

	snape_always picked Remus: Sirius was James' best friend but remus was everyone's friend and most importantly he was nicer to severus. posted over a year ago.

	Flickerflame picked Remus: The sensible ones posted over a year ago.

	Tasha1993 picked Sirius: The idea that Remus and Lily were friends before she dated James is only in fanfics. There's not canon info of them being friends, but I'm sure they were at least after she started dating James.But before James, I don't think so. At least Lily wrote a letter to Sirius. But she didn't mention Remus in that letter. Plus, Remus doesn't talk about her either. That line he says in the film is not canon and doesn't make sense either. So she might not have been that close to Remus. posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	LowriLorenza89 picked Remus: ^Anything in the films is secondary canon unless it's countered by something in the books. posted over a year ago.