Would Claire have actually died if Sylar had taken her powers in five years gone? Poll Results - Heroes

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Heroes Would Claire have actually died if Sylar had taken her powers in five years gone?

171 fans picked:

Yes

51%

Maybe (if the pieces werent all there!)

27%

22%

TopCrock posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

12 comments

	tubby2002 picked Yes: Without a brain I dont think she could heal herself, remember when she had the autopsy, she was dead until the woman pulled the stick out of the back of her head, the same way peter was until the glass was taken out of the back of his head posted over a year ago.

	harold picked Yes: Wha...? It's clear that the powers reside in the brain, so yeah. posted over a year ago.

	TopCrock picked No: I'm not so sure... It might be cellular... and if her brain was replaced would she still be alive? Does Sylar actually physically remove his victims brains? I just wanted to hear some ideas and opinions! posted over a year ago.

	SnifSharpee12 picked No: no because when Sylar tried to take Peter's brain he regenerated his skin before Sylar could even open him up. So if Sylar tried to take Claire's brain then she could just heal again. It's not like he's stabbing something into the back of her head posted over a year ago.

	hak picked Yes: Isn't that Charlie in the first picture? posted over a year ago.

	yessur081 picked Yes: She can only regenerate when the item that's killing her is removed, but if there was a key piece of her, like a heart or brain missing, she wouldn't be able to function.....therefore live. posted over a year ago.

	berriesrbest picked Yes: The 5 years older Hiro said that she would have. posted over a year ago.

	unfair_love picked No: I agree with SnifSharpee He tryed it on Peter... and failed If he tried it on Claire IT WOULDN'T WORK posted over a year ago.

	Amberla picked No: Yes she would have been dead but on the other hand I don't really think so... She can heal and it's not like Sylar placed a piece of glass in her forehead (Peter died when he got a big piece of glass in his forehead)... posted over a year ago.

	Sylarfan picked Maybe (if the pieces werent all there!): Even though in Season 3 when Sylar took her power she didnt die I think the writers intended for her to die in this episode posted over a year ago.

	Silphaer picked Maybe (if the pieces werent all there!): Only if he had actually taken her brain out. Spoiler warning: Watch reborn. She is dead. posted over a year ago.

	Flickerflame picked No: As shown in season 3, being Sylared isn't enough to kill her. posted over a year ago.

Add Your Comment

Heroes

Heroes Would Claire have actually died if Sylar had taken her powers in five years gone?

12 comments

Sign In or join Fanpop to add your comment

Heroes more polls