Harry Potter

answer this question

Harry Potter Question

why does harry start seeing the thestals from the 5th book?

i mean he did see cedric dead, but hadn't he seen his parents (or at least his mother) dying when he was one year old??? shouldn't he be able to watch them from his first day at hogwarts? (or righter on the third year coz in the first they used boats and in the second the went on ron's car)


????
why does harry start seeing the thestals from the 5th book?
 Irina92 posted over a year ago
next question »

Harry Potter Answers

xoxJoJoRulesxox said:
I always took it as he doesn't remember seeing his motherdie, considering he was only one.
However he saw Cedric die right in front of him, so thats why he can the Thestals
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
oh thx! i haven't thought of it... but still, he does see green lights in his dreams...
Irina92 posted over a year ago
Nahla1309 said:
he hasn't seen his parents getting killed, at least not james... lily was in his room when voldemort entered and killed her but i'm not sure that that counts cause harry was only one year old.. we don't know if he was sleeping or looking in another direction when his mother was killed.. and i'm not even sure he realized what was happening so that's maybe why he hasn't seen the thestals from day one at hogwarts...
he has seen cedric dying in the forth book, he was looking right at him and was very conscious of it..
at least that's what i think =)
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
thakns a lot! you know i've noticed that u always give good answers in questions.. you seem to be a great hp fan! u should be dedicated fan or sth! ;)
Irina92 posted over a year ago
*
thanks =) well for know i don't have enough time to be around (i'm finishing high school and have a lot of exams) but hopefully i'll find time during the summer holidays =)
Nahla1309 posted over a year ago
*
I the movie Voldemort was facing Harry with the window behind them. So it is assumed that Harry did not see Lily die behind him. And I agree on James being killed before hand.
jacob020 posted over a year ago
jacob020 said:
Honestly, I'm not sure they thought that through. B/C you do have a point. But in the movie, Lily was by the door and Harry was facing the window. James was already dead. The book gave no decriptions on that note. So that's my best answer.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
ok thx for answering anyway! but i have to say that it's a bit confusing that subject...
Irina92 posted over a year ago
*
yeah it's really confusing!! I couldn't understand it until u put this question...good...
Natalia94 posted over a year ago
*
thx! yep i read one more time the 5th HP book and that caught my eye...;)
Irina92 posted over a year ago
Natalia94 said:
I always though that Harry just didn't understand what was going on and that's why when he saw cedrik
dying he realized what he saw so that's the reason why he sees the thestrals in the 5th Harry Poter book..I think so...
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
lemon1110 said:
He sees them bECAUSE IN BOOK 4, THE GOBLET OF FIRE, HE SEES CEDRIC DIGGORY , PLAYED BY ROBERT PATTENSON, DIE TRYING TO SAVE HIMSELF FROM VOLDEMORT. AND STRANGLY ENOUGH NEVILLE LONGBOTTOM SAW IT TOO....
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
yes and then cedric turned into a sparkley vampire named edward and lived happily ever after with bella :) sorry i had to add that when i saw his name on here lol
CULLEN-HALE posted over a year ago
No0o279 said:
<<<<< Probably because he was just and wasn't aware of what was happening and can't remember the incident plus we saw in the movie when voldemort killed his mom he was in her arms so he maybe didn't really eye witnessed the exact second of the mother dying hope you understand what i'm trying to say i'm not really that good at explaining myself ^_^ >>>>>>>.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!