answer this question

Glee Question

A Theory`s going around about episode 4 Season 3 (more info inside) - What do you think?

There`s a theory going around amongst a few Glee fans (I`ve seen mainly on youtube comments)that Quinn could be behind the whole Shelby/Puck thing!

A few people have the theory that this whole thing could be Quinn`s way to prove Shelby is an unfit mother & that somehow she`s convinced Puck to help her by "seducing" Shelby - meaning a teacher having a relationship with a student!


I feel this could be possible but seems unlikely as it would very out of character for Shelby who seems very professional & despite Puck`s love of older women he really has grown up since season 1 & seems to genuinely like/care about Shelby & want to be there for Beth.

What do you think?
(Keep in mind this is only a theory!)
*
SPOILER: It`s rumoured that the episode could end in a Shelby/Puck kiss!
MontanaGirl2892 posted over a year ago
 MontanaGirl2892 posted over a year ago
next question »

Glee Answers

ForsakenMoon19 said:
Hmmm I see your point in this. In episode 2 Quinn was dead set on doing what ever it took to gain full custody of Beth and now with Puck on her side it looks as though the two of them might be in this scheme of seducing Shelby and perhaps get her in trouble with the school district. This could also effect Shelby's glee club if there's no director leading them. I want to think Quinn isn't going to stoop this low as to get Puck to seduce Shelby but clearly the girl is in a messed up state of mind to think rationally. Then again we know what kind of person Puck is and lately he's been feeling kinda down since the whole Lauren thing, he might be on the rebound. So what better way for this to work out. You got Quinn willing to do whatever it takes to get her baby back, using Puck's assistance to make it happen and then you got Puck (who's a known sex shark) possibly looking for love in all the wrong places, while also wanting to be apart of Beth's life. I think he might use his own child as an excuse to get close to Shelby and the result might become a demented love triangle. Puck might start developing real feelings for Shelby (as he spends more time with her) or he just might become caught up in a lustrous phase (The Mrs. Robbinson syndrom). And Quinn might start developing feelings for Puck, not just wanting Beth back but possibly jealous of Shelby/Puck and wanting to become a family with him. This scenario can go any way, I prefer if Quinn wasn't involved in the affair as it'll just make her look worse and nonredeemable. Puck on the other seems to do no wrong with the fans no matter how much he screws up, though I'm guessing his actions with Shelby might take a toll on the Puckleberry and Quick fan bases.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Thanks for answering - always great to hear your opinion : ) I think Quick could still happen but it`s certainly gonna take a knock & as far as Puckleberry I really don`t know, all I can say is if Shelby/Puck do more than kiss *gag* there`s defiantly no chance of Puckleberry again but I hope they can somehow be friends! x
MontanaGirl2892 posted over a year ago
*
^See even I don't think Rachel could forgive Puck for sleeping with her mom let alone kiss her if it got that far. I'd imagine she'd be more than disapointed in him but I could be wrong, maybe she won't care. Either way I predict Quick will happen but that won't stop the Quick & Puckleberry fans from bursting a blood vessel once the Shelby/Puck thing take off:/
ForsakenMoon19 posted over a year ago
*
I was/ still kinda a Puckleberry fan (more friendship than romantic) & I also like Finchel & I`ve recently started liking the idea of Quick- I`m pretty easy going! But to be honest even if I didn`t ship any of these couples the idea of Shelby/Puck would still repulse me as much as it does now x
MontanaGirl2892 posted over a year ago
*
^Your not alone there, it repulses me as much as it does you....*EWwww*
ForsakenMoon19 posted over a year ago
next question »