Disney Princess Question

If Charlotte had kissed Naveen while not being a princess......

.....shouldn't she turn into a frog, too? Mama Odie says that if they don't kiss by midnight, the spell wouldn't break because Charlotte would no longer be a princess. If Tiana turned into a frog while kissing Naveen because she wasn't a princess, shouldn't Lottie have turned into a frog, also? I hope you get what I'm asking

wow...how could i have missed that? i guess i agree with firegirl1515's first option, but...wow.

percyandpotter posted over a year ago

madisonsavanna posted over a year ago

next question »

Disney Princess Answers

firegirl1515 said:

Wow, MAJOR inconsistency! How did I not notice that? Well, I figure that it's for one of two reasons:

A) That whole "if he kisses someone that's not a princess they turn into a frog too" thing only applies once.

B) Naveen didn't actually kiss her back, so it didn't really count. After the clock struck twelve, he stopped puckering and basically stopped trying. He was just standing there- Charlotte was the only one who really did any kissing. Stupid, I know, but that would explain it.

They really should've clarified that in the movie. That's a really big plot hole.

Wow, MAJOR inconsistency! How did I not notice that? Well, I figure that it's for one of two reasons:

[b]A)[/b] That whole "if he kisses someone that's not a princess they turn into a frog too" thing only applies once.

[b]B)[/b] Naveen didn't actually kiss her back, so it didn't really count. After the clock struck twelve, he stopped puckering and basically stopped trying. He was just standing there- Charlotte was the only one who really did any kissing. Stupid, I know, but that would explain it.

They really should've clarified that in the movie. That's a really big plot hole.

posted over a year ago

kiraragirl200 said:

Maybe since Facilier died, that part of the spell could've broke. Maybe that's what caused her not to turn into a frog.

posted over a year ago

TigerRanma said:

I remember someone asked this too, on youtube. I think someone tried to explain by saying that it was because Dr Facilier was dead or his amulet was broken. But I really don't know.

posted over a year ago

kenzieiscool said:

Wow I never thought about that! You're right, she should of turned into a frog! Ah well, when it comes to movies, you do what's right for the story to move on I suppose.

posted over a year ago